In Defense of the Humble Bread Machine


This post may contain affiliate links. Please read our Disclosure Policy for details.


People either swear by their bread machine, or wouldn’t be caught dead with one in their kitchen. I know and love some in each camp. Myself, I’m a convert.

I grew up in a house where everything was made from scratch. In fact, we didn’t even use the term “from scratch” because it was redundant. Everything was homemade, from cakes and cookies to stuffing and bread; I don’t think I ever saw a box mix in the house.

Making bread at home was no exception; it was not uncommon to come home from school and see the mounds of dough, covered with a thin towel or sheet of plastic wrap, in the rising stage on the kitchen table. And then, a few hours later, the mouthwatering smell of fresh bread just out of the oven. The last step, keenly watched by my sisters and me, was the brushing of melted butter over the tops of the hot loaves.

I still make everything from whole ingredients, and bread is no exception. Five-pound bags of flour are on our weekly shopping list. If that sounds expensive, then consider the price of a loaf of bread! I make all of our bread, from weekly sandwich bread. to French or Italian loaves when an occasion calls for it. Also sourdough…but that’s another topic altogether.

For all of my bread making, I now use a bread machine. Years ago we were given a Sunbeam 2-Pound Programmable Breadmaker by a neighbor, who had one and didn’t use it, and wondered if we would. I said sure, let’s try it. Well, we tried it, and the bread maker is now an essential part of the kitchen.

What a bread machine can do for you:

  • Automate the process of timing and kneading, freeing you to just go about your business and listen for the beep.
  • Mix, rest, knead and bake bread for you.
  • Make dough for pizza, dinner rolls, and more. Also cakes and jams, though I haven’t tried these yet. (Did I mention pizza dough? Homemade pizza!)

Reasons you might NOT need a bread machine:

  • You have time to watch the clock and relish the idea of springing to the kitchen for the next step. (Mostly joking here, though I have failed at this more than once.)
  • You enjoy the laborious process of kneading. If you have the time and enjoy it, keep doing what you’re doing!
  • You don’t like pizza. (But seriously, give homemade pizza a try!)

How does a bread machine work?

Simple: You measure and add all of the ingredients and turn on the machine. The bread maker stirs, rests, kneads and bakes your bread. Then you pop the hot loaf of the pan. Done!

Cons to using a bread machine?

There will be a paddle gap in your loaf. The bread pan has a small paddle (or two, depending on your model) that mixes the dough. The paddle stays in there while the bread bakes, and it leaves a gap and creates a little tear when the loaf comes out of the pan.

(I don’t bake my bread in the machine. Instead, I take the finished dough out, shape it and place into two loaf pans to rise and bake. Does this defeat the purpose of the bread machine? Not at all! The machine still does most of the work, and I have two loaves instead of one. I like small slices.)

Pizza and more

I mentioned pizza. Have you ever made homemade pizza? If you thought it was too much work, you have to try making crust in a bread machine.

I recently made dinner rolls to bring to a party. Other guests were astounded that they were, in fact, homemade. “Did you really make these from scratch?” Yes, I measured the flour and butter and salt. When I mentioned that I used the bread machine, there was a little confusion. Yes, the bread machine can bake a loaf of bread. No, it cannot divide dough into 24 neat dinner rolls; I did that part by hand. But if it were not for the bread machine, I can tell you I would not have endeavored to make homemade dinner rolls for a party!

After many years of weekly breadmaking, our faithful bread machine finally quit. I researched as I shopped for a replacement, thinking we’d upgrade to a nicer one. Guess what? After all my research, I ended up buying EXACTLY THE SAME  Sunbeam 2-Pound Programmable Breadmaker again! It’s a good one.

Do you make your own bread, and if so do you use a bread machine?

Between the Stumps is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for sites to earn advertising fees by advertising and linking to


    1. You’ll love it! I’d never even considered a bread machine until our neighbor offered hers. I’m so glad she did. 🙂 Thanks for reading.

  1. I love fresh bread, I may just need to add this to my wish list! As a kid my mom had one, I remember it always feeling like a gamble if it was going to turn out right! Its been nearly 2 decades…. so I’m thinking I’ve gotta give it a go!

    1. I adapted a standard bread machine recipe until I was happy with it. I make that recipe every week for sandwich bread, and it’s been very consistent and reliable. Hope you decide to try it out!

  2. I used to use mine a lot and then it broke., and I never replaced it. I make my bread by hand now (but not all the time) and enjoy the kneading when I’ve got some angst to get out, lol. However, this post made me miss my machine!

    1. You make bread by hand, I’m impressed! I used to do that occasionally, but rarely, I admit. It wasn’t until we got the bread machine that it seemed doable every week. Thanks for reading!

  3. No shame! I used to LOVE my bread machine before I went gluten free. I mean…fresh bread! And so easy! Way better than anything store bought!

  4. We got a bread machine for our Wedding back in 1995, and we still take it out occasionally. I never thought to let the machine do the work and then bake it in loaf pans – thanks for the great idea!

    1. Hi Vicki, I baked bread right in the machine at first but was never fond of the awkward loaf size or the paddle gap. It does take a little extra work to knead and shape the loaves, but totally a matter of choice!

    1. What a great idea! I’ve never made cinnamon bread…must try that soon! Let me know if you have a good recipe to share. 🙂

  5. To be honest, we received a bread machine as a wedding gift 14 years ago and I have no idea what ever happened to that thing! I actually completely forgot about it until I read your post! I do recall enjoying the smell of fresh baked bread when we used it. I think it’s time to revisit that machine 🙂

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *